Source:Proceedings of the 40th SEFI Annual Conference 2012 - Engineering Education 2020: Meet the Future
(2012)
The purpose of this paper is to delineate core features of successful cross-disciplinary collaboration, and to consider how to bring these features into engineering education so that engineering students are better equipped for future interdisciplinary work. Despite a consistent interest in interdisciplinarity in education in the last decades, there are still conceptual inconsistencies and confusion surrounding the term. It is the integrative aspect, which is at the heart of interdisciplinarity, denoting the synergetic interaction between specific disciplinary perspectives. However, current university structures inhibit the integration of multiple disciplinary perspectives into a more comprehensive approach to problem solving. Meanwhile, the industry is increasingly in demand of graduates with strong interdisciplinary skills. The present paper is guided by the following research question: What are the implications of interdisciplinarity for engineering education, and how would an enhanced interdisciplinary thinking influence curriculum planning? The present study points at the development of cross-disciplinary collaboration skills in real-life settings as instrumental to building interdisciplinary competence. The various forms of problem and project based learning practices employed in many engineering educational settings may include an interdisciplinary dimension, which is though often challenged by current university structures and traditional disciplinary boundaries. Consequently, collaboration is limited to working in homogeneous groups on mutually agreed projects, with little scope for developing crossdisciplinary collaborative skills, i.e. the ability to negotiate conflicts, integrate expertise from related fields, and produce flexible, innovative solutions - all of which qualify students to work in the type of independent, interdisciplinary project teams, increasingly in demand by industry. Our aim is to raise awareness of this gap and suggest a framework for integrating interdisciplinary collaboration competencies into existing problem and project based learning curricula. The data in this paper originates from the setting of an annually recurring, three-day-long digital building workshop, "Digital Days" (henceforth DD), that brings together industry specialists, university and vocational training staff, as well as exponents of the entire range of professionals populating a building site. students and trainees engage collaboratively on a common digitalized design platform, the Building Information Modeling (BIM) method. BIM design tools allow for extracting different though automatically consistent views from a building model for various uses enhancing the integration of the design process. Being the meeting point, building models facilitate the coordination and collaboration between parties. BIM alters the cross-disciplinary approach used in the industry today, since it is only possible if the processes are iterative, and disciplinary contributions are continuously being merged into the project. BIM both requires and supports interdisciplinary collaboration and it is therefore suggested as a means to include interdisciplinarity in engineering programs. One of the salient features in our findings was the aspect of collaboration between participants from the various disciplines, who not only benefited from working in a team, but also from the process of negotiating solutions with concurrent teams. Participants mobilized communicative skills in order to uncover each other's "ways of thinking and practicing" and the underlying principles of specific disciplinary methods in order to distill the problem solving approach. Moreover, the students gained more confidence in approaching problems. The experimental learning climate boosted participants' spirit of inquiry and freedom to advance viable solutions to the open-ended problem. The dynamic social milieu promoted mutual commitment and motivation to comply with the constraints of a product oriented approach, where interdisciplinary collaboration was instrumental to project work. Regarding the interdisciplinary objective in problem and project-based learning models employed in engineering education, our findings suggest that there may be further scope for interdisciplinary collaboration, at both intra-departmental and faculty level, and the wider social context including the industry. Socially facilitated learning environments created by real-life problem scenarios and the coexistence of diverse disciplinary perspectives are seen as main qualifiers for students engaging actively in interdisciplinary project teams. In order to promote the development of interdisciplinary collaboration skills among engineering students, the interdisciplinary competence has to be explicitly acknowledged as a learning goal in the educational program. Besides the formal, curriculum level, a framework for integrating the development of interdisciplinary competence in engineering education should involve the organizational and instructional levels, i.e. explicit ways of organizing interdisciplinary learning opportunities, as well as the competence development level, i.e. equipping staff with the required insight and tools to facilitate students' learning processes.
The purpose of this paper is to delineate core features of successful cross-disciplinary collaboration, and to consider how to bring these features into engineering education so that engineering students are better equipped for future interdisciplinary work. Des
…
Keywords:
CurriculaEngineering educationPersonnel trainingEducation computingIterative methodsProduct designstudentsProblem solvingeducationComputer aided instructionProblem- and project-based learningInterdisciplinary collaborationsCollaborationinterdisciplinarityInterdisciplinarityArchitectural designCollaborationBuildingsBuilding Information Model - BIMProblem and project based learningCross-disciplinary approachesCross-disciplinary collaborationsInterdisciplinary competence
Concern about the rising cost of a college education, the growing need for remedial and developmental education among first-time college students, and low persistence and graduation rates among the most atrisk college students
Research into social stratification and social divisions has always been a central component of sociological study. This volume brings together a range of thematically organised case-studies comprising empirical and methodological analyses addressing the challenges of studying trends and processes i
…
In the United States, formal Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) programs have been a part of the United States educational landscape for almost a 100 years, since the first U.S. federal legislation, the Smith-HughesAct, was passed in 1917 to approve funding for these programs. In
…
The importance of communication skills for engineering professionals is widely acknowledged. Research in the authors' group indicates that along with other cognitive and behavioral skills, employers of new engineering graduates place high value on communication skills. Here, the authors argue that b
…
There is a growing concern in the United States regarding the declining state of education and college enrollment for degrees in the areas of Science, Technology, Engineering and Math (STEM). As part of a STEM Outreach program, The MITRE Corporation is partnering with educational foundation organiza
…
Keywords:
ApprenticeshipInternshipProfessional aspectsEngineering educationPersonnel trainingapprenticeshipEducation computingengineeringeducationSTEMeducationInternshipCareer academySTEMEmerging technologiesengineeringEducational experiencescareer academyScience , Technology , Engineering and MathematicsEducational organizationsSocieties and institutions
The 'tribes and territories' metaphor for the cultures of academic disciplines and their roots in different knowledge characteristics has been used by those interested in university life and work since the early 1990s. This book draws together research, data and theory to show how higher education h
…
This study explores women's experiences with project-based learning within the context of introductory engineering courses at two community colleges and one four-year institution. The study was framed by Bronfenbrenner's (1979) ecological systems theory [Bronfenbrenner, U., The Ecology of Human Deve
…
Keywords:
Project-Based LearningEngineering teamsFemale engineering students
Kelly Ritter and Paul Kei Matsuda have created an essential introduction to the field of composition studies for graduate students and instructors new to the study of writing. The book offers a careful exploration of this diverse field, focusing specifically on
…
The Project-based learning of Web Quest could improve the students' research positivity and also the abilities of getting all kinds of resources online. And the important way for them is to quest information independently on the internet via the induction of the
…
Keywords:
E-learningTeachingProject based learningDesigndesigncommunicationEducational resourceDesign and DevelopmentJoint developmentdistribution systemDistribution systemswebquestNET technologyPrimary and secondary schoolsPublishing systemsWebQuest